Free job offer comparison

How to compare two job offers, side by side

The headline salary is only one line. Put the offers next to each other on what they're really worth over a year, and on the things that matter to you, then decide. Paste each offer below, or add a screenshot or PDF of each.

For two to four options, like phone plans, builders' quotes, job offers or insurance renewals: a plain table on the things that matter, with the cost maths shown.

What to compare, line by line

  1. Total pay over a year.

    Salary plus any guaranteed bonus, allowances and the employer's pension or retirement contribution. A bonus that's "up to" or "discretionary" isn't guaranteed: count it separately.

  2. Benefits with a money value.

    Health cover, insurance, meal or travel allowances, learning budgets. If an offer doesn't mention one, ask: "not stated" isn't the same as "not included".

  3. Time.

    Holiday days, working hours, on-call or weekend work, and the commute. Two extra hours of travel a week is over 90 hours a year.

  4. Flexibility.

    Days in the office, remote options, and whether they're in the contract or "at the manager's discretion".

  5. Commitment.

    Probation, notice period, any clawback of a signing bonus or relocation costs, and restrictions on where you can work next.

  6. Stock or equity.

    What kind, how many, when they vest, and what happens if you leave. Its future value is unknown, so keep it apart from guaranteed pay.

The pressure to expect

Questions to ask each employer

Decision Coach never tells you which job to take. It lays both offers out on the same lines, shows the sums, and says which offer does better on each thing you said matters. For a contract clause you're unsure about, ask an employment adviser or lawyer.

Questions

How do you compare two job offers?

Put them on the same lines: total pay over a year (salary, guaranteed bonus, employer pension contribution), benefits with a money value, holiday, hours and commute, flexibility, and commitment (probation, notice, clawbacks). Then weigh those against what matters most to you.

Is it OK to ask for more time to decide on a job offer?

Yes. Asking for a few days to review the written contract is common and reasonable. A calm, specific request works: "I'd like until Tuesday to review the contract."

How should I count stock options or equity?

Keep them separate from guaranteed pay. Note how many, the type, the vesting schedule and what happens if you leave. Their future value is unknown, so Decision Coach lists them without adding a guessed value to the total.

Will Decision Coach tell me which job to take?

No. It works only for you and never picks for you. It shows the offers side by side with the maths, the pressure in either offer, what would change the answer, and questions to ask each employer.

Do you store the offers I paste?

No. What you paste or upload is sent to Anthropic, our AI provider, to do the comparison, and isn't stored by Kindyra OS.

More from Decision Coach